Shenzhen links the steady department and drafts doctors and patients' dispute and deals with the draft and receives much concern

Shenzhen links the steady department and drafts doctors and patients' dispute and deals with the draft and receives much concern
Shenzhen links the steady department and drafts doctors and patients' dispute and deals with the draft and receives much concern
Because discontented treatment, the patient family members and social personnel increase year by year to the example that the hospital commits offenses, Shenzhen links the steady department to draft <>(hereafter referred to as " method ") ,The legal system office of the city reviewed the draft the day before yesterday, the content initiated all circles to discuss. " the method " forbids disease relatives to assemble a crowd " Demand the statement " ,Introduce the people and mediate the mechanism as mainly handling the way, forbid " fight " , the encouragement " The verbal struggle " . Some disease relatives think, it is the key to mediate the efficiency of the organization, the hospital expects the new method has more intact auxiliary laws. Meanwhile, the society worker gets involved but seekers too on the road mediated. Forbid assembling a crowd " Demand the statement " May 25, the intersection of infant and Zheng of Guangdong move in horizontal the intersection of hillock and the intersection of the People's Hospital and the intersection of pediatrics and treatment with serious the intersection of disease and pneumonia, the condition is aggravated sharply on May 27, the children's hospital of Shenzhen rotates to rescue the death of failing to respond to any medical treatment. Infant relatives think horizontal hillock the People's Hospital has not treated in time, causes child death. Several dozen unidentified identity personnel four degrees attack the hospital, limit medical worker's freedom of person. At the night of June 3, the police of dragon's hillock take measures, detain 10 participants, in that verify some jobs " medicine make a noise " . Every hospital of Shenzhen reflects, the case quantity of the medical dispute rises year by year, the social personnel by making a living by solving doctors and patients' dispute increase specially, commonly called as " medicine makes a noise " . Under help of them, set up the mourning hall, type banners, even stops up the conflict of the first aid passway and take place in hospitally occasionally. " the method has been " strengthened correctly " Medicine makes a noise " Attack. To neither mediating, nor solving the dispute through the judicial route, take too drastic means to besiege the medical organization, upset the working order of normal medical treatment by force, ones that damage medical worker's personal safety as well as the property safety, are punished or taken the compulsory measure in accordance with the law by the public security department. Shut and assemble a crowd " Demand the statement " Door,open " the method " door that be mediated,it set up by " doctors and patients dispute mediate at existing people's mediation committee per street by operating room " to plan . Does the patient pay close attention to the fact " why relative go to things that the hospital safeguards the rights to appear again and again to mediate efficiency? Our patient relatives are forced, " Because the brother-in-law's death, Miss Wang and more than 10 relatives had typed banners to safeguard the rights outside a hospital of Luohu District together last month, as to " method ", her view is unexpected, " we would like to resolve the problem peacefully too, but can not really dawdle! " Miss Wang says, the brother-in-law's case has already entered the legal procedure at present, has found out about many relevant cases too by oneself, if quick, can wait for from 3 months to half a year adjudicate; If slow, " see on TV someone won the lawsuit after waiting for whole 19 years " . Doctors and patients have many disputes to get up because of injuries and deaths, but the persons who die have already died, living people will live, relatives have been originally already sad endlessly, mostly hope to finish the relative's body funeral affairs as soon as possible, "take my brother-in-law and say, stop in the funeral parlor, costs 100 yuan each day, really can't tow. " Have the wait-and-see attitude on " method " in the review, her, " I think, see efficiency in key, want, run the the intersection of doctors and patients and dispute that set up, mediate how loudly it will be department's power in street? Give the final word and solve the problem, OK? There are preliminary solutions, the procedure goes also wanting the first grade grade? If like that, do not mediate course procedures, spoil the effect by adding what is superfluous? " One insisting on anonymity interviewee admit oneself " make by medicine " with job once Keep in touch, conflict with a hospital of Longgang District, it seems to accelerate to some extent to compensate for the process afterwards, "originally the disparity of both sides was very great, after making a noise, the attitude of the hospital seemed to relax some, having settled and compensated quickly, divided 30% for those ' medicine made a noise ' later, in any case, the thing is solved a bit faster. " Miss Wang thinks, even if someone asks to " cure and make a noise " Also excusable, " it is sometimes really very helpless, we are very rational, but can't solve towing all the time. " The hospital expects that " our doctor is the disadvantaged groups to issue the related system! The patient comes to cure the disease, has cured OKly, go wrong whether it is the doctor's responsibility, create a disturbance first " ,Speaking of doctors and patients' dispute, the south mountain director of office of the People's Hospital Zhu HongQian says, hospital want, face patient, at a disturbance of the intersection of everything and piece often, scold people, hit the person, take place occasionally, some even spread the paper money big inside the hospital. Commit offenses as to the patient, Zhu HongQian says, if the interference goes to the hospital to work normally, encroach on other patient's rights and interests, the hospital will call the police, but can not sustain the person committing offenses to come everyday, "if individual follows a president and runs everyday, follow a doctor and make a noise, which medical personnel has attention to work, who still does meeting the operation that may be risky next time? The injured one is still the patient. " Zhu HongQian says, if ordinary citizens make a noise and return, is most afraid of running into the job " medicine makes a noise " ,Some even have a background of reactionary gang, have listened to " your doctor come off duty a bit more carefully " In that case, doctor on tenterhooks, the intersection of some and " medicine make " Even organize a lot of people to besiege the hospital collectively, stop up the way and commit offenses in the street. Zhu HongQian says, sometimes can run well for the hospital, in order to safeguard the social stability, even not one's own responsibility, the hospital has to " shoulder the thing on the upper shoulder " . "This is not a basic method which solves the problem, it is not all right to solve doctors and patients' dispute and only lean against administrative department of the hygiene and hospital, "Vice floormanager of Shenzhen Municipal Health Bureau Xie RuoSi says. Zhu HongQian says, the hospital does not oppose a patient complains, the patient can come to " demand the statement " ,But there should be a proper route, he thinks that it is perhaps a good method to look for such a third party of insurance company. It is reported, the medical liability insurance has been already regarded as the medical personnel's professional liability insurance the American-European developed country to list in the legal insurance category at present. And the keys to this system, all present the medical dispute, investigate, mediate, compensate and is taken charge of by specialized insurance company employee, its third party's neutrality helps to give up doctors and patients' suspicion of both sides, contribute to relieving contradictions of doctors and patients. While meeting and asserting the difficult dispute, can be transferred to the medical dispute arbitration organ to assert in accordance with the law. The gentle director of subject of medical matters of the People's Hospital of Shekou has more expectation on new method, "in fact, the relevant department solicits our opinion before drafting. From the viewpoint of us, certainly hope to standardize this, but only depend on this " method " may not be enough, also need more complete related system. " She thinks, " method " already revealed can let doctors and patients both sides reduce the front conflict, but the legislative authority of dealing with malpractice conflict is that the malpractice made many years ago handles the regulations, " the method " need fitting law, " after incident happen, can let, handle course, must implement according to " way " in accordance with the law. " The residential district has already to mediate had before dawn on April 26 of precedent, because an infant coughs, suffers from diarrhoea to dragon's emergency department of central hospital in the hillock to go to a doctor, the condition took place suddenly in the course of infusing and treating Change, die after all rescue measures proved ineffectual, back relative its gather 40 over people stop up the hospital gate, then the one that stop up in front of the hospital door also favours the highway deeply, cause the traffic to stop up for more than one hour seriously. "Such an incident happens, it is usually unable as the hospital, can only seek help from the government. " The Longgang District staff members of health bureau say, after this incident happens, let Ministry of Health and hospital deal with, patient will distrust, feel " a trench " Will mutual shelter. So the health bureau proposes that units such as street and local police station,etc. mediate the third party, mediating will be scheduled 4 of the same day afternoon: 15 go on, doctors and patients the intersection of both sides and every group does not exceed, attend, can mediate by 5 representative of person. Suffer from spokesman Fang and state the whole story and demand, hospital's spokesman makes explanations and responds to suffering from the square demand, because the mediation of the third party gets involved, both sides agree to trust the southern judicial expertise centre of medical university to carry on autopsy finally, find out the death reason, further consult, has prevented doctors and patients both parties from sticking to one's own view, form the deadlock, cause upgrading and deterioration of the colony incident. Longgang District health bureau say have the precedent, they and street, bureau of justice of district and hillock of dragon run and consult, use the intersection of our country and other the intersection of province and the intersection of urban area and experience for reference, make " the intersection of dragon and the intersection of hillock and dispute, doctors and patients of central hospital, mediate the implementing scheme " (discuss the draft) ,The scheme proposes setting up doctors and patients' dispute to mediate the operating room (call medicine in the following text and adjust the room) in pilot project of the street of dragon's hillock Imagination,is it dragon hillock to last unit in charge of centre's, Longgang District local police station lasting member unitting administration of justice, let dragon hillock street, district health bureau, medicine, have a full-time staff member, is responsible for accepting and mediating the application. Bureau of justice and district health bureau of dragon's hillock set up law expert's storehouse and medical expert's storehouse to offer two great professional support respectively at the same time. The ones that have still cured and adjusted duty, job requirements, working way and doctors and patients' dispute in the room to mediate clearly in scheme have accepted the condition, mediated the workflow, the operability is stronger. Solicit every hospital and relevant unit opinion extensively after making, has got support from everybody in scheme, especially every hospital has placed the great expectations on implementation of this scheme. Society worker get involved, may expect society worker big to become Engineer, society of medical matters, never in Feng, this 23 -year-old girl in Tianjin is studying how to undertake the numerous and jumbled social work on the hospital rapidly. At present, many city owned hospitals are from the non-commercial organization " charitable public service network " altogether Having bought the service of 8 society workers, like Feng Wei, they are together with own social working office of the hospital, do the best to lighten the burden for the hospital doctor. The social work office of Shenzhen BJ Univ Hospital thanks you for saying frankly brightness, they used the Hong Kong experience for reference at that time, solve some duties that the dispute becomes the engineering department of the society. The new medical reform scheme issued before this points out clearly, the engineering personnel of medical matters society can serve as " lubricant " among doctors and patients . Under most situations, doctor of every department, head nurse will phone Feng Wei, reflect there are needs the sudden incident dredged exist, has already made her up to one's eyes in work even if it is so passive a working way, the hospital is considering whether to engage one more society worker, undertake the social duty. Deal with little dispute, society worker serve as third party roles often, promote doctors and patients to conciliate; While meeting the dispute difficult to solve, are mainly appeared by the social work office. Xie JunHui says she and colleague is making great efforts to adjust working way, idea, "the care of human nature is very important, should show loving care for the other side even more when there are disputes, consider how to relieve, understand it in terms of angle, people of the social work, doctors and patients are no longer opposite, there is involvement of third party, worker of society, are solved and promotes the dispute certainly too. " This edition pool: Leaf hurricane of reporter of deep city This edition is interviewed and written: Leaf hurricane of reporter of deep city Liu Yong This edition photographs: The reporter of deep city is old by cherishing nobly and refinedly The new policies are clicked and hit Set up in every street people's mediation committee of the whole city " Doctors and patients mediate the operating room in dispute" ,Mediate doctors and patients' dispute in time. Forbid any individual or unit to go to the medical organization to assemble a crowd and demand the statement with any reason, upset the working order of normal medical treatment of the hospital. The medical organization must cooperate with on one's own initiative and investigate and handle, can't avoid, delay or obstruct with any reason. Mediate and does not charge any expenses of doctors and patients' both sides, is not mediated the number of times to limit either. Mediating the result base on the premise that doctors and patients both sides accept has legal effect. Encourage Shenzhen every large medical organization, buy medical liability insurance, until " whether doctors and patients' dispute mediate the operating room " Mediate, arbitral award or the people's court judgement confirms compensating, the safety unit must compensate to the patient in time. Strengthen it correctly " Medicine is at a disturbance of personnel " Personnel's attack with making trouble wilfully. To neither mediating, nor solving the dispute through the judicial route, take too drastic means to besiege the medical organization, upset the working order of normal medical treatment by force, ones that damage medical worker's personal safety as well as the property safety, are punished or taken the compulsory measure in accordance with the law by the public security department. According to <>(Some ) The case is chained A woman cures cold and makes and hangs the needle death on January 15, more than 10 men and women go to the funeral parlor to rob the corpse. After, country of boy, die of illness March 12, parents and relative lift cardboard, claim salt the intersection of harbour and hospital manage child extremely in the intersection of salt and the intersection of harbour and the intersection of hospital and gate, district of salt pan, initiate and surround and watch. Because an infant is serious disease and pneumonia died after all rescue measures proved ineffectual on June 3. The infant family members and four degrees for several dozen unidentified identity personnel attack a hospital, limit medical worker's freedom of person, police detain 10 people. More than 10 people wear to have on June 16 " Wrong " Getting white T shirt of word, pull out banner, assemble in front of one the intersection of women and children and hospital, safeguard the rights for death, baby of caesarean birth.


|